Conflicts of Interest Policy
CITI Science Journal is committed to ensuring that editorial decisions and peer-review processes are fair, objective, transparent, and based on the scholarly merit of submitted manuscripts. A conflict of interest may arise when personal, professional, financial, institutional, or other relationships could influence, or reasonably be perceived to influence, an individual's judgment or responsibilities in the publication process. The journal requires authors, editors, and peer reviewers to disclose relevant conflicts of interest and to take appropriate steps to ensure the integrity and impartiality of editorial decisions.
Conflicts of Interest for Authors
Authors must disclose any financial or non-financial interests that could reasonably be perceived as influencing their research, interpretation of results, or manuscript. Relevant interests may include, but are not limited to:
- Employment, consultancies, honoraria, or other payments.
- Research funding, grants, sponsorships, or other financial support.
- Ownership of shares, patents, or other financial interests related to the work.
- Personal, family, or close professional relationships that may affect objectivity.
- Institutional affiliations or competing academic interests.
- Other relationships or circumstances that could reasonably be perceived as influencing the research or its reporting.
All authors are responsible for ensuring that relevant conflicts are disclosed accurately and completely. If no conflicts of interest exist, authors must include a statement such as: “The authors declare no conflicts of interest”. Funding sources and the role of funders in the design, conduct, analysis, interpretation, or publication of the research should be disclosed separately where applicable.
Conflicts of Interest for Editors
Editors must not handle manuscripts where their personal, professional, institutional, financial, or other interests could compromise, or reasonably appear to compromise, their impartiality. Editors must disclose relevant conflicts and withdraw from the editorial assessment and decision-making process when necessary. The manuscript will be assigned to another qualified editor who can make an independent decision. An editor's involvement as an author or co-author of a manuscript does not permit them to make decisions concerning their own submission. Such manuscripts must undergo the journal's standard editorial assessment and peer-review process under the supervision of an independent editor.
Identification and Management of Conflicts
The journal evaluates disclosed conflicts on a case-by-case basis. Depending on the nature and significance of the conflict, appropriate measures may include:
- Requesting further disclosure or clarification.
- Assigning an independent editor or alternative reviewer.
- Excluding a conflicted individual from editorial deliberations or decisions.
- Requiring additional disclosure in the published article.
- Taking other appropriate measures to protect the fairness and integrity of the publication process.
The existence of a conflict does not automatically mean that a manuscript must be rejected. The journal's response will depend on the circumstances and whether the conflict can be appropriately managed.
Disclosure and Publication
Relevant conflicts of interest must be disclosed during manuscript submission and, where appropriate, included in the published article.
Authors must inform the editorial office promptly if a relevant conflict arises or is identified after submission. If a previously undisclosed conflict is identified after publication, the journal will assess the matter and may publish a correction or take other appropriate action in accordance with its publication ethics policies.
Responsibilities and Compliance
All authors, editors, and peer reviewers are responsible for providing accurate disclosures and cooperating with reasonable requests for clarification. Failure to disclose a relevant conflict of interest, or the provision of misleading information, may result in editorial action, including reassignment of the manuscript, rejection, or post-publication corrective action, depending on the circumstances. The Editor-in-Chief or an authorized independent editor is responsible for overseeing the implementation of this policy and ensuring that conflicts are managed fairly and consistently.
