Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy
CITI Science Journal recognizes that artificial intelligence (AI) and AI-assisted tools may support research, writing, translation, and scholarly communication. The journal permits responsible use of such tools while maintaining academic integrity, transparency, originality, and human accountability. This policy applies to authors, editors, peer reviewers, and other individuals involved in the preparation, evaluation, and publication of manuscripts submitted to the journal.
Use of AI by Authors
Authors may use AI-assisted tools to support language editing, translation, and improvements in clarity and readability. However, AI-generated or AI-translated text must be carefully reviewed, verified, and revised by the authors to ensure linguistic accuracy, appropriate academic expression, and fidelity to the intended scholarly meaning.
The journal strongly recommends that authors whose manuscripts are written or translated into English with the assistance of AI, or who are not confident in their academic English, obtain professional English-language editing by a qualified academic language editor before submission. Professional language editing can help improve grammar, terminology, clarity, coherence, and adherence to academic writing conventions.
The use of AI tools must not replace the authors' own intellectual contributions, critical thinking, or responsibility for the accuracy and integrity of their work. Authors must verify all factual claims, references, data, and research findings, and must disclose substantive use of generative AI in accordance with this policy.
Obtaining professional language-editing services does not guarantee acceptance or influence the editorial decision. All manuscripts remain subject to the journal's standard editorial assessment and peer-review process.
Disclosure of AI Use
Authors must disclose the use of generative AI tools when such tools have made a substantive contribution to the preparation of the manuscript, including the generation or substantial revision of text, the creation or modification of figures or images, or assistance with data analysis, coding, or interpretation.
The disclosure should identify the AI tool used, its purpose, and the relevant parts of the work where appropriate. This information should be included in a dedicated AI-use statement or another section specified by the journal.
Routine spelling checks, grammar correction, and basic language editing that do not substantially generate or alter scholarly content generally do not require disclosure.
Authors must verify all AI-generated content and ensure that citations, references, data, and factual claims are genuine and accurate. AI-generated references must not be included without verification against reliable sources.
Authorship and Accountability
AI tools, including generative AI systems, cannot be listed as authors or co-authors because they cannot take responsibility for the work, approve the final manuscript, or fulfill the duties of authorship.
All listed authors must meet appropriate authorship criteria and accept responsibility for the integrity and accuracy of the work. The use of AI does not reduce or transfer the authors' responsibility for the manuscript.
Research Integrity and Prohibited Uses
AI tools must not be used to engage in or facilitate research misconduct, including:
- Fabricating or falsifying research data, results, or evidence.
- Generating false or unverifiable citations and references.
- Plagiarizing or presenting others' work as original.
- Creating or manipulating images in a way that misrepresents research evidence.
- Concealing material AI involvement where disclosure is required.
- Violating confidentiality, privacy, copyright, or other applicable rights.
Any AI-assisted analysis, coding, or interpretation must be appropriately verified by the authors, and relevant methods should be described where necessary for transparency and reproducibility.
Use of AI by Editors and Peer Reviewers:
Editors and peer reviewers must protect the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and all related editorial communications.
Manuscripts, reviewer reports, unpublished data, author information, and other confidential materials must not be uploaded to or shared with external AI tools unless such use is expressly authorized by the journal and consistent with applicable confidentiality, privacy, and data-protection requirements.
AI tools must not replace the independent professional judgment of editors or peer reviewers. Editorial decisions and peer-review recommendations must remain under human responsibility.
Editors and reviewers must not use AI tools to reproduce, disclose, or otherwise misuse confidential manuscript content.
Editorial Assessment and Compliance
The editorial team may request clarification or additional information about the use of AI in a submitted manuscript when necessary.
Potential concerns will be assessed individually and in context. AI-detection tools or automated assessments must not be treated as conclusive evidence of misconduct on their own.
Failure to disclose material AI use, or the use of AI in ways that compromise research integrity, may result in a request for clarification or revision, rejection of the manuscript, or other appropriate action under the journal's publication ethics policies.
If concerns arise after publication, the journal may take corrective action in accordance with its policies on corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions.
Policy Updates
CITI Science Journal may update this policy as AI technologies, scholarly publishing practices, and relevant ethical standards evolve. Authors, editors, and reviewers are expected to comply with the version applicable to their work.
